UNOFFICIAL — an independent student guide, not affiliated with USMLE, NBME, NRMP, LCME, or AAMC. Part of the SI MedEd family

Step 1 in the pass/fail era.

Since January 2022, Step 1 no longer reports a three-digit score — it reports Pass or Fail. The exam didn't get easier. The bar got slightly higher, the failure rate roughly doubled, and a failing result now stands out more than ever in residency applications. This guide explains what changed, what the national data show, and how to prepare with a clear head.

Unofficial guide. This site is an independent educational reference. Policies, eligibility rules, and the passing standard can change — confirm current details at the authoritative sources: usmle.org and nbme.org. We are not affiliated with the NBME, USMLE program, NRMP, LCME, or AAMC.

91%US MD first-time pass rate, 2024 (down from 96% in 2021)
194→196passing standard raised when pass/fail began
2×first-time failure rates roughly doubled after pass/fail began

What changed in January 2022

The pass/fail effect

In January 2022, the USMLE program switched Step 1 score reporting from a three-digit numeric score to a simple Pass/Fail result. The change was intended to reduce the overemphasis on a single number in residency selection and to refocus the exam on its original purpose: a licensure-level check that a student has mastered the basic-science foundations needed to care for patients.

But the exam itself did not become easier. At the same time reporting changed, the minimum passing standard rose from 194 to 196, and the observed result was that the national failure rate roughly doubled. For US MD first-time test takers, the pass rate fell from 96% in 2021 (the last numeric-score year) to 93% in 2022, then 92% in 2023 and 91% in 2024. For US DO first-time takers, the drop was sharper: from 94% in 2021 to 89% in 2022, 87% in 2023, and 86% in 2024. (Source: USMLE Performance Data, published by the USMLE program.)

Step 1 first-time pass rates, by year (national)
YearUS MD first-timeUS DO first-time
2021 (last numeric-score year)96%94%
2022 (pass/fail begins, Jan 2022)93%89%
202392%87%
202491%86%

First-time pass rates only (not eventual/overall rates). Source: USMLE Performance Data, published by the USMLE program. National rates continue to be updated yearly; treat these figures as snapshots through 2024.

Why "just passing" still demands respect

A fail is a career variable

It is tempting to read "pass/fail" as "lower stakes." The national data say the opposite. Failure rates roughly doubled after the change, and a failing result now carries outsized weight precisely because almost everyone is expected to pass on the first attempt. The NRMP's program-director survey — which tracks the factors directors weigh when selecting applicants to interview — includes failed Step attempts as an interview-selection factor. A single fail becomes one of the most visible lines on an application.

Our read: pass/fail also shifted the competitive weight toward other parts of the application: clerkship performance, Step 2 CK scores, letters, research, and demonstrated fit. None of that changes the fundamental task for Step 1 itself. The goal is a confident pass — not a high score, and not a bare-minimum scrape. Students who aim for "just barely passing" leave no margin for a bad testing day, and the data show that margin matters.

The bottom line for your planning. About 1 in 10 US MD first-time takers and about 1 in 7 US DO first-time takers did not pass in 2024. That is a real, non-trivial risk — and it is manageable with the right preparation, the right readiness checks, and the discipline to delay if you are not ready. This site is built around that mindset: prepare like the pass is not guaranteed, test when you are ready, and pass once.

Start here

Everything on this site

SI MedEd family

More guides from the same family

SI Step 1 is one of five new SI MedEd sites, alongside the flagship portal and the USMLE overview hub.

Sources

Where the numbers come from